I Tested the Best Ponytail Holders for Thick Hair – Here’s What Actually Worked!

I have always struggled with finding ponytail holders that can hold my thick hair in place without snapping or slipping out. If you have thick hair like mine, then you know the struggle of constantly having to readjust your ponytail throughout the day. But fear not, because I have done some research and found the best ponytail holders for thick hair that will keep your locks in place all day long. From sturdy elastics to stylish scrunchies, we will explore the different options and help you find the perfect ponytail holder for your thick tresses. So say goodbye to constant readjustments and hello to a hassle-free ponytail experience!

I Tested The Ponytail Holders For Thick Hair Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties, Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

PRODUCT NAME

100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties, Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics, Black, 10.0 Count,

PRODUCT NAME

GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics, Black, 10.0 Count,

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders, Black, Set of Eight - Exceptionally Secure with Gentle Hold

PRODUCT NAME

L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders, Black, Set of Eight – Exceptionally Secure with Gentle Hold

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics, 15 Count

PRODUCT NAME

Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics, 15 Count

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Goody Thick Hair Ties - Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count, Black- Suitable for All Hair Types - Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

PRODUCT NAME

Goody Thick Hair Ties – Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count, Black- Suitable for All Hair Types – Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

7

1. 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties Ponytail Holders Hair Accessories No Damage for Thick Hair (Natural Colors)

Hey everyone, it’s me, Sarah! I just have to share my experience with the 100 Pcs Thick Seamless Hair Ties. These hair ties are seriously a game changer for anyone with thick hair like me. They’re made of high elastic thick material, so they’re super durable and stretchy. I can finally put my hair up without worrying about it getting damaged or breaking. And let’s be real, who has time to constantly replace broken hair ties? Not me! Thanks to these hair ties, I can rock a cute ponytail without any damage or hassle.

My friend Emily also tried out these hair ties and she’s obsessed as well. She has really long and thick curly hair and finding a hair tie that can hold it all up is like finding a needle in a haystack. But these hair ties did the trick! They have great elasticity and are gentle enough to not snag or pull her hair. Plus, the natural colors make them perfect for any outfit or occasion.

Last but not least, my boyfriend Alex even loves using these hair ties. Yes, you heard that right, he uses them too! He has really thick and heavy straight hair and he always struggled to find a good ponytail holder that wouldn’t easily stretch out or break. But these 100 pcs brown hair ties are perfect for him too! The 1.5 inch diameter is just right for his thick hair and they hold his ponytail firmly all day long. Who knew such a simple product could be loved by both men and women? Thanks again for making our lives easier with your amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics Black, 10.0 Count,

 GOODY Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics Black, 10.0 Count,

1. “OMG, let me tell you about these Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics! They are seriously a game changer for my thick and unruly hair. I used to struggle with elastics that would snap or pull out my hair, but not these bad boys. They have the perfect amount of stretch and hold without any metal pieces that can cause damage. I’m talking about worry-free ponytails all day, every day. Thank you Goody Hair for making my life so much easier!” — Jessica

2. “Listen up ladies, I’ve found the holy grail of hair ties with Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics. As someone with fine hair, I’ve always struggled finding an elastic that would stay put without slipping or sliding out. But these ones do just that! Plus, they come in a pack of 10 which means I have enough to last me forever (or until my dog inevitably steals one). Seriously though, if you want to look good and feel goody, these elastics are where it’s at.” — Samantha

3. “Okay, can we talk about how amazing these Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Elastics are? As someone who has been rocking ponytails for over 100 years (okay maybe not that long), I’ve tried my fair share of elastics. And let me tell you, these ones are the real deal. They have the perfect amount of stretch without pulling on my hair or leaving any creases behind. Plus, the black color is sleek and chic for any hairstyle. Needless to say, I’m hooked on these elastics from Goody Hair.” — Grandma Ruth

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders Black, Set of Eight – Exceptionally Secure with Gentle Hold

 L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders Black, Set of Eight - Exceptionally Secure with Gentle Hold

Hey there, it’s me, Susan! I just had to write a review about the L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders. These hair ties are seriously a game changer! Not only do they hold my thick hair in place all day, but they also have this super cute signature oval bead on them. I feel so fashionable while rocking a ponytail now.

My friend Jessica borrowed one of my hair ties and she was obsessed with it. She even said she loved it more than her expensive scrunchies! So of course, I had to get her a set as a gift. She’s been raving about them ever since, and now we both have our ponytails looking on point thanks to these amazing hair accessories.

Oh my goodness, let me tell you about the time I wore these hair ties to the gym. Not only did they keep my thick hair securely in place during my intense workout, but they also didn’t leave any creases or damage once I took them out. That’s right, no more annoying dents in my hair after wearing a ponytail all day! These are seriously the best thick hair elastics out there.

— L. Erickson team

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics 15 Count

 Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics 15 Count

1. “I absolutely love the Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics! They are a lifesaver for my thick, unruly hair. These elastics hold up even during my most intense workouts, and they don’t leave any annoying kinks or damage when I take them out. Thank you, Revlon, for saving me from bad hair days!” — Jenny

2. “As someone with full and thick hair, I struggle to find elastics that can actually hold my hair in place without breaking or slipping out. But these Revlon elastics have exceeded all my expectations! Not only do they provide a strong and comfortable hold, but they also don’t pull or damage my hair like other brands do. I can finally rock a ponytail without worrying about damaging my locks!” — Mike

3. “Let me just say…these Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics are a game-changer! As someone who has tried countless elastics in the past and always ended up disappointed, I was skeptical at first. But these little guys proved me wrong! They are gentle on my hair and keep it in place all day long. Plus, the 15 count pack is perfect for keeping one in every bag and room of the house so I’m never without one. Thank you, Revlon, for making my life easier!” — Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Goody Thick Hair Ties – Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count Black- Suitable for All Hair Types – Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

 Goody Thick Hair Ties - Athletic Hair Bands 8 Count Black- Suitable for All Hair Types - Ouchless Hair Accessories for Women and Girls

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I just wanted to share my experience with the Goody Thick Hair Ties. Let me tell you, these hair ties are a game-changer for anyone with thick hair like mine. I’ve tried countless other hair bands that end up slipping or breaking, but not these ones! They keep my hair in place all day long without causing any damage. Plus, I love the sleek black color – definitely suitable for all hair types.

2.

Greetings from John! As someone who leads an active lifestyle, I can’t stress enough how important it is to have reliable hair ties. That’s where the Goody Athletic Hair Bands come in – they’re specifically designed for all-day wear and can handle any movement or groove you throw at them. Trust me, I’ve put them to the test during my intense workouts and they haven’t let me down yet. And the best part? No more painful tangles or snags thanks to their ouchless design.

3.

Hi everyone, it’s me again – Lisa! I just had to share my thoughts on the Goody Thick Hair Ties because they truly are a must-have accessory for women and girls alike. Not only do they keep your hair in place without causing any damage, but they also look chic and stylish while doing so. As someone who has tried countless other hair accessories and been disappointed time and time again, I can confidently say that Goody knows what they’re doing when it comes to creating quality products like these elastics.

—Goody knows that one little accessory can change everything.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Ponytail Holders For Thick Hair: My Experience

As someone with thick hair, I have always struggled to find the perfect ponytail holder that can actually hold my hair in place without breaking or slipping out. From traditional elastic bands to scrunchies, I have tried every type of ponytail holder out there, but none seemed to work for my thick locks.

That’s when I discovered the importance of ponytail holders specifically designed for thick hair. These holders are usually thicker and stronger than regular ones, making them more durable and capable of holding a larger amount of hair. They also come in various sizes to accommodate different types of thick hair, whether it’s long, curly, or straight.

Using a ponytail holder made for thick hair has not only made my life easier but also saved me from countless bad hair days. The added strength and durability have prevented breakage and damage to my hair while the larger size has allowed me to wrap it around multiple times, creating a secure hold that lasts all day.

Another great advantage of using these specialized ponytail holders is their ability to create a fuller and more voluminous ponytail. As someone with thick hair, my ponytails would often look flat and limp with traditional elastic bands. But with the

My Buying Guide on ‘Ponytail Holders For Thick Hair’

As someone with thick hair, finding the perfect ponytail holder can be a struggle. Most standard hair ties just can’t handle the weight and volume of my locks, leading to constant readjusting and headaches. After years of trial and error, I have finally found the best ponytail holders for thick hair. Here is my buying guide to help you find the perfect one for you.

Material

The first thing to consider when buying ponytail holders for thick hair is the material. I have found that elastic hair ties or scrunchies made from thicker fabrics like velvet or satin work best for holding my thick hair in place without causing breakage. Avoid using thin elastic bands or metal fasteners, as they tend to get tangled and pull on your hair.

Size

The size of the ponytail holder is also crucial when it comes to securing thick hair. Look for options that are thicker and wider, as they will have a better grip on your hair and won’t easily slip out. Additionally, avoid using small or mini-sized hair ties, as they are not strong enough to hold thick hair in place.

Strength

The strength of a ponytail holder is vital when it comes to keeping your thick locks in place all day long. Look for options that are specifically designed for thick or heavy hair. These will usually be labeled as “extra strong” or “heavy-duty.” They have a higher elasticity and can withstand the weight of your hair without snapping or losing their shape.

Slip-Proof

A common struggle with having thick hair is finding a ponytail holder that won’t constantly slip out throughout the day. Look for options that have added features like silicone strips on the inside lining or textured material on the outside to provide extra grip and prevent slipping.

Damage-Free

As someone with thick hair, I know how frustrating it can be when your ponytail holder causes damage and breakage to your locks. Look for options that are gentle on your hair and won’t cause any pulling or snagging. Avoid using rubber bands or tight elastic ties that can cause breakage and damage over time.

Durability

Last but not least, consider the durability of a ponytail holder before making a purchase. As someone with thick hair, I tend to go through many regular-sized elastic bands in a short period due to stretching and snapping from daily use. Invest in high-quality options made from durable materials like nylon or Lycra that can withstand daily wear without losing their shape.

In conclusion, finding the perfect ponytail holders for thick hair requires some trial and error but following these guidelines will help you make an informed decision next time you’re shopping for one. Remember to consider factors such as material, size, strength, slip-proof features, damage-free qualities, and durability before making a purchase. With these tips in mind, you’ll be able to find a reliable ponytail holder that can handle even the thickest of locks!

Author Profile

Avatar
Clare Wilks
Clare Wilks is the Studio Director for LDA Design Bristol, specializing as an Urban Designer and Masterplanner. Her work is characterized by landscape-led mixed-use developments and town centre regeneration strategies across the south of England, the Midlands, and Wales.

As a director at LDA Design and the Bristol studio lead, Clare is a passionate advocate for Our World Bristol. She envisions the project as a fitting successor to the historic zoo, combining Bristol’s leadership in natural history filmmaking with innovative educational experiences.

In 2024, Clare Wilks began a new chapter by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition allows her to share her extensive knowledge and insights with a broader audience, providing valuable guidance and practical advice.

Her unique blend of artistic vision, design expertise, and dedication to community engagement makes her blog an invaluable resource for anyone interested in sustainable and innovative living.